Curse of the Tires
![]() |
| A.I. generated photo of my flat tire and where I was last week, though the flat tire and beach weren't at the same time. |
Just a couple days before our expected departure, we were on our way to Christmas Eve mass and I glanced down at the digital cluster display and noticed that one tire only had 11 pounds of pressure in it compared to the others with 36 pounds. I have only 3600 miles on these tires so I was pretty sure it wasn't the tire sensors themselves. When I pulled into our parking spot at the church, I walked around and yes, it was definitely very low.
I have been cursed with tires of late it seems. On my previous vehicle, I have blogged about the expensive run flats that come on it because the all wheel drive (AWD) feature of it means there is no room to store a spare tire. Run flat tires, while handy to have, are super expensive to replace. On my first long road trip, I was pulling over to a curb in a no parking area in downtown Charleston, South Carolina for a quick, and safe peek at my phone to ensure I was heading the right direction. I ended up pulling just a little too close to the curb that happened to be lined with very sharp rocks for some reason and immediately slashed the sidewall. Fortunately being run flats, I was able to drive on to the local dealership where some $1200 later, I had four new run flats installed. With AWD, the tires need to be fairly matched in size to ensure you don't destroy that transmission and all my tires were half worn at that point necessitating four new tires instead of just one.
A year later on another long road trip, heavy downtown traffic in Denver swerved just in time for me to see a huge crater of a pothole that I couldn't avoid, rupturing the sidewall of another tire. Once again, I drove onto the nearest dealer and $1400 later, I had four new tires for the same reason mentioned above.
I won't go into details but I think I only wore one set of tires completely down on that van in all the years I owned it and spent countless thousands of dollars replacing half worn tires due to the AWD system and because they were run flats. The day I traded it in for my new ride, was a happy day indeed, at least until two and a half months later when I discovered it was extremely low in the church parking lot.
After Christmas Eve mass, I walked out to discover it was very low at that point but the rim was still above ground. The digital display now registered 0 pounds of pressure but there was a gas station just two blocks away and I thought if I could drive really slow, I might make it there and be able to air up the tire enough to get home and deal with the situation on Christmas day. I did make it there but they didn't have any air hose to inflate tires and so I changed the tire, installing the spare right there in the parking lot, in my church clothes and in the rain. Fortunately this vehicle doesn't have run flats and even though it still has AWD, it has room for a spare tire.
I made it home and tried to forget about it all Christmas day and hoped to deal with it on the Friday afterwards. I first went to the dealership where they found a screw causing the flatness but it was in the sidewall and not repairable. They did not have a tire that fit in stock. I drove down the road to a tire shop that has a single tire in stock that would work and for $230, I was on the road. This time, I lucked out since all the tires were fairly new, replacing it with a new tire meant it was close enough in tire diameter not to cause problems with the AWD system. I got lucky. To ward off any potential spirits, I bought a tire plugging kit to carry in the vehicle just in case.
With the tire fixed, we are packing today and away early in the morning on a long road trip. Hopefully I left the tire curse at home for the duration of this trip.

That is funny as in odd. My tires, both summer and winter, are more than 10 years old. My mileage is so low that they haven't yet insisted that I change them out. Hopefully, this trip will go well.
ReplyDeleteIt did go well with no further tire issues. But someday before I leave this earth, I would like to run one set of tires all the way to the wear bars.
DeleteWow, this is too much tire excitement and expense! My 2018 Forester has a spare tire and I would prefer to have one although I've read (since you brought it up) that many (most?) new cars have the run flat instea of spare tires.
ReplyDeleteI will never buy a car with run flats again if I can help it. I suspect that is why new Siennas now have a spare tire instead of run flats like mine did. They were nothing but expensive and not that good of a ride either since they have such stiff sidewalls. Despite the screw, I felt quite happy only to have spent $230 instead of $1400+.
DeleteEd, I can't believe how much you've spent on tires! Wow. And now two of our three cars are AWD, so I better watch the pavement!
ReplyDeleteBoth my eldest daughter and wife drive AWD cars and have no issues with tires. I think it was mostly that vintage of Sienna and just plain bad luck. My current vehicle is also AWD but at least it doesn't have run flats so the tires are much more reasonably to buy, nearly half the price!
DeleteWhat is a run flat? Is that what I'd call a "donut tire" that tides you over until you repair the flat? Are you on a trip now or was this written right after Christmas?
ReplyDeleteA run flat is a tire that has very stiff side walls and it met to be driven on for up to around 50 miles at speed allowing one to presumably drive somewhere convenient to get it fixed or replaced. They take the place of a donut since you can still drive on them for a limited amount of time. I wrote this on the day after Christmas and the day before we left on vacation.
DeleteIt is a good thing you found out that you had a problem and didn't ride around on the rim! I have run flat tires - still don't understand how that works but so far so good.
ReplyDeleteThey just have side walls that are very stiff and can support the weight of your car for a limited amount of time until you can get the tire fixed or replaced. With non run flat tires, the side walls will allow the rims to touch the ground and get damaged meaning a more expensive repair.
DeleteEd, this has always been my caution in thinking about an AWD.
ReplyDeleteI don't think I wrote things very well as I have absolutely no issues with AWD and living where I do, I will never buy another vehicle that isn't AWD. AWD is fantastic! I just wouldn't buy a car where the design doesn't allow it to have a spare tire and so one is forced to use run flat tires instead.
DeleteTalk about inconvenient timing. Sheesh. I'd not heard of run flat tires either, but then I don't get out much. I guess they're worth the price. Ed, I hope 2026 is a better tire year for you!
ReplyDeleteIf you can't change a tire and having a flat might mean hours or days sitting in a vehicle or walking to the nearest phone, run flat tires have their place. But 99.9% of my driving is somewhere were I could call a tow truck if needed so I can't justify the expensive of having tire "insurance". Changing the tire on Christmas Eve to put on the spare certainly wasn't convenient but I got it done and I'm glad I didn't have to buy another set of expensive tires to fix the issue the day after Christmas.
DeleteIn the UK it has been standard for many years now to not provide a spare, just a "puncture repair kit" - basically a tube of foam gunk that you inject into the flat that's supposed to fill the puncture and allow reflation, so that you can drive. Problem is that the gunk wrecks the tire so have to replace anyway.
ReplyDeleteAlso, all cars have to be fitted with tire pressure warnings, but these don't normally show actual pressure, just use some algorithms to sense when any tire is loosing pressure. This means that you can easily drive on a partially deflated tire for some distance before the low pressure is sensed, and usually wreck the sidewalls, so have to replace anyway
I'm familiar with the tire gunk and try to avoid it at all costs. After this experience, I did buy a tire plug kit so do some minor repairs that might get me a bit further down the road but I still need to obtain a portable air compressor or just put on the spare and then after airing up the plugged and repaired tire, swap it back on.
DeleteMy last car sensed tire pressure but would only notify me if it was below 20 psi. This one tells me the actual pressure which is kind of handy. It has also been a neat experience monitoring how weather and driving time changes the pressures within each tire.
I've had similar tire issues on our Subaru. I put a new set on and within a couple of months I hit a curb and destroyed one tire and hit a piece of metal on the highway and destroyed another. I do like the dashboard tire pressure display on this car. When the tire pressure light comes on, I can put on the display that shows the current pressure and instantly know which tire is low. On a recent flat, the warning light popped on and I looked at the details and could see the pressure dropping quickly on the tire which told me to get to the side of the road quickly.
ReplyDeleteI did similarly though when I noticed that my tire was low on the way to church (11 psi), it held constant for the duration of the drive which was about three miles. However when I started it up after church, it said 0 psi. I'm guessing the leak was slow until perhaps the tire got flat enough that it stressed the hole area and then let out the last little bit more quickly. At least that is my theory.
DeleteI am speechless. Had I been you, I would have had plenty to say that would not be appropriate for this forum. As we say in the South, bless your heart.
ReplyDeleteHad it just been me, I would have said some choice words too. But it was Christmas Eve and the car was full of my family so I held my tongue and just went to bed early when we got home. I was in a better mood by Christmas morning.
DeleteBoy, do I remember those days. It's been years since I've owned a car and had to deal with tire problems -- maybe as much as 40 years -- but it is not fun.
ReplyDeleteIf I had adapted to live in a large urban city, I wouldn't own a car either. I have always found mass transportation incredibly convenient and cheap to use. But there is this thing about all the people...
Delete