Mom's Tip
My wife had a milestone birthday a few weeks back and to celebrate, we went out to eat at a new(ish) fancy steakhouse that opened up in a new motel in town earlier this spring. It is a chain known for their fancy steaks though neither of us much care for steaks in a restaurant setting. My wife got the chicken and I got the fish, both delicious and both a small fraction of the price of their steaks. We enjoyed the meal tremendously but due to the high price (much much less than had we ordered steaks) we probably won't return anytime soon.
However, our server for the night was extremely nice. He perfected the service by making us feel welcome and engaging us in the right amount of conversation without feeling over bearing. Our waters were constantly topped up and he was more than happy to fulfill any requests we had. My wife, near the end of the meal, asked me if he was in the running for "Mom's Tip."
I had never heard my wife refer to it as such but instantly that notion grabbed me and I think I will run with it. Somehow in her later years, my mom told me that she had gotten in the habit of tipping a well deserving restaurant server with a $100 bill, usually sometime during the holiday season. After her death, my wife and I decided to continue that tradition and we have for five of the last six years. For some reason last holiday season, we just didn't go out to eat or weren't in a situation with a good server and never carried it out. I have had that $100 bill stuck in my wallet ever since then and it has been bugging me.
My wife and I don't eat out a lot. It isn't particularly healthy to begin with and also my wife's schedule is such that she is often too tired to eat out on weekdays and on weekends, cooking meals at home is her form of stress relief. When we do eat out, we often go to the same two or three places and I think it would be uncomfortable for the server and us both if a large tip came between us. I want the person gifted "Mom's Tip" to feel grateful and happy, not beholden to us if that makes sense.
So after our meal at the fancy steakhouse, I agreed with my wife that we should give our server "Mom's Tip," the one I didn't hand out last year. For several reasons, I paid by credit card and just added the tip to our bill instead of putting in a zero on the tip line and leaving the $100 bill tucked into the bill holder jacket. We left quietly, not drawing attention to what had transpired, not always possible in the past, and went home imagining our server's surprise and hoping he puts it to good use.
A few days later, for other reasons, I had to look up a charge on my credit card statement and noticed that my tip hadn't been charged. Instead, our exact bill without a tip was charged. I was instantly confused. Had our server thought we were pandering to his polite conversation when we asked about his family in response to a question he had asked us? We were genuinely interested and I didn't want him to feel that way. So after talking it over, my wife and I agreed to wait a few days and see if for some reason the charge changed to include the tip. If it didn't, we were prepared to call the restaurant and inquire about it and explain the reason we gave the large tip in memory of my mom.
But four days later, when I checked a second time, the charge had been upgraded to include "Mom's Tip." I don't understand the logistics of why the tip needs a few extra days to be added but I'm happy our server received it. I hope it brings him happiness. I hope Mom is happy. I know it made me happy being able to give to someone who definitely deserved it.
What a lovely thing to do! But I won't be copying the idea of "Mom's Tip" as I am a mean and miserly sucker. Getting money out of me is like getting blood out of a stone.
ReplyDeleteI know you are a secret push over YP!
DeleteOh Ed. Don't you know you're suppose to also post a picture of your dinner? ;-)
ReplyDeleteThis wasn't the type of place where I could take an indiscreet picture.
DeleteI am confused yet again. Why would a cash tip show up on your bill at all? Is it a tax situation? And why on the credit card statement? Please help. I am old and Canadian, eh?
ReplyDeleteI think it's a great thing that you did, inspired by your mother.
But I am also confused by the fact that you aid your wife likes to cook. I don't think that I have ever met a woman like this.
Normally I give a cash tip just in case the establishment shares tips among all servers equally. This allows the server to decide whether they report it or just pocket it. But in this instance, there was someone with us watching my every move and I didn't want a $100 bill to be observed being put in the bill holder and so I just added the amount to the tip line to be charged to my credit card.
DeleteAh. 👍
DeleteI like that you do this and think it would be fun to be a fly on the wall (well, maybe not a fly in a restaurant!) and see the server's reaction.
ReplyDeleteA couple times in the past, making an exit before being discovered hasn't been an option and the reaction has been very grateful. But I still prefer to be somewhat anonymous in the giving in case our paths cross again. I don't want them to be beholden to us due to the one tip.
DeleteI think it's a wonderful tradition. I'm an overtipper by nature but not at that level. :) Happy Birthday to your wife!
ReplyDeleteI would like to think we tip generously for those deserving, every time we eat out which isn't often. I look at this as hopefully helping in a more significant way for someone who works in a poorly paid profession, normally during the holiday season when money may be tight. This one was an exception as I'm sure the wait staff at this restaurant were paid a lot better than average and it wasn't near the holidays.
DeleteThat is a very nice tradition! My friend's mother was a waitress at the Kahala Hilton (when it was called that) and there were lots of wealthy repeat guest staying there and eating at the fine restaurants. One of her regular customers was not coming back anymore and fond farewells were done. She later found his tip on the table. It was a key - to a brand new full size Mercedes Benz in her name. That was a tip!
ReplyDeletePerhaps someday I might be able to do something as generous!
DeleteYou really make somebody's day with that tip.
ReplyDeleteI hope so. Regardless, I always feel a little bit better about my life after leaving such a tip.
DeleteThat is a great idea Ed.
ReplyDeleteI honestly do understand how charges work. Some clear in a day, some take a week or more.
But is it normal for the tip part to clear nearly a week after the original charge? My best guess is that the initial charge was somehow entered into the system in order to return my credit card and receipt for a signature and then the tip didn't get run through until later in the week when perhaps all tips were run through at once, maybe for economic reasons.
DeleteWhat a great idea! I bet you made his day! Too bad tips are taxed:(
ReplyDeleteI get that but I also see a giant loophole that would be taken advantage of if they weren't. Everyone would just work for tips. However, I'm guessing those earning tips under our current tax laws, for the most part, get all their taxes refunded in April as the bottom 50% of all taxpayers pay 0% net taxes.
DeleteThis is a lovely idea. I worked as a server many, many years ago, and know how difficult it is to work hard at less than minimum wage (because tips were supposed to make up for it). I never got a mom's tip, but know I would have been exceedingly grateful for it.
ReplyDeleteWe try to single out service staff that is working hard because I assume they might appreciate it more than the person just skating by. They usually have a need and thus the willingness to work to fill that need.
DeleteIt's a great way to honor your mom AND to honor a conscientious worker.
ReplyDeleteI have felt the same about it!
DeleteThat's such a nice gesture and a wonderful tribute to your mom.
ReplyDeleteThank you.
Delete