Judging Readers By the Covers
Once every year, our community has a big book sale to raise money for the local library. For most of the previous year, boxes of books were collected in a few locations, mostly people dropping off ones they no longer wanted. Those books were eventually consolidated to an upstairs floor of a venue where later the book sale will be held. This year by the luck of being in the wrong/right place at the right/wrong time, I was asked to volunteer in sorting those books into various categories and I accepted.
An hour later, I was up on the second floor, pulling books out of a large cardboard box and putting them on other tables in one of about two dozen different categories. It wasn't a lot of heavy lifting but it was quite a bit of walking. What I enjoyed the most however was pulling books out of a box and mulling over who the reader might have been or what the reader was like.
Boxes full of romance novels likely belonged to older women (and perhaps some younger) who had not had good luck in the romance department for one reason or another. Other boxes full of westerns were likewise, probably older men looking to escape the realities of their current life by reliving days long past. Occasionally there were boxes full of random novels and some non-fiction but not often. For every three boxes mostly full of westerns or romance novels, we might see a box with something else in it.
One box I sorted were fictional western books, every single one of them, except one. The one odd ball was "Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee" is a non-fiction book that I have read that recounts the systematic destruction of Indians in the second half of the 19th century. Judging from its more pristine cover compared to the well worn of the pulp westerns that filled the box, it was obvious to me that whomever bought it solely based upon the name and after discovering what it was about, immediately stopped reading it.
Others, left me completely befuddled, such as the guidebook to 1980's San Francisco that had an entire chapter devoted to the best S & M Bed and Breakfast places in the city. I had no idea such things existed and not I'm slightly worried that I may accidentally check into one someday and wake up tied to my bed. The other two people helping me sort and I pondered whether we should even put it out since it is dated and questionable in the subject matter department but all being someone liberal thinkers when it comes to reading material, put it in the Travel section all the same. One of the others commented that we should tag it to see who buys it. I immediately said I had no desire what so ever to know who buys it. Such knowledge like that might change my perspective entirely if it were someone I knew.
Besides judging those who read the books previously, I was also somewhat judging the books themselves. My favorite title of the day goes to a book called "The Chocolate Clown Corpse" by Joanna Carl. I have no idea what the book was about but whomever came up with the name and the cover design, a chocolate clown shoe with a large bite missing out of it, is surely a genius.
The name of it escaped my mind but I found a book, several hundred pages long, broken into chapters full of possible phrases one might see in a romance novel in a particular situation. My neighbor happens to be a romance novelist of some fame and was one of the people sorting so I showed her the book. She was less than thrilled about the author of that book. I wasn't sure of all the reasons why but I wasn't interested enough to ask any further.
Finally after several hours, we were all tuckered out from walking perhaps miles on concrete to deliver books to the correct category so they can be properly staged the weekend of the book sale. I gave the other two my number if they needed any more help later on as the sale is still a month away. One advantage to volunteering is that as I sorted through the few non-fiction books, I picked out a few that looked really interesting (that I haven't already read) and took them home with me with a promise to settle up on the day of the book sale. Working with a romance novelist and a fellow more interested in DVD's which we also collected and sorted versus books, I didn't have any competition over the books I had found. They each had stacks of their own.
Haha! The best S&M bed and breakfast places!! My God, to think it got its own book! Well Ed, I can't believe it's been a year since your last book gathering I remember this very well. Sounds like some sweaty work, but seeing gems like that book above and The Chocolate Clown Corpse makes it seem worthwhile. 🙂👍
ReplyDeleteWell the entire book wasn't about S&M B&Bs. Just one chapter. I forget the title but I think it was something along the lines of LGBTQ (forgive me if I get the letters wrong) Guide to San Francisco.
DeleteHow interesting Ed, and what an unintentional insight into book donators (and, I might add, a nice way to pre-view any books that interest you).
ReplyDeleteReading only non-fiction, not a lot interested me. But, whenever I did come across a donated box with a lot of non-fiction in it, my sorting time got extended quite a bit.
DeleteChurches occasionally have to purge their library. I once remember someone finding and reading out loud a title, "Searching for Sodom and Gomorrah." "That sounds like a racy novel," I said. It was about someone scuba diving in the Dead Sea, but later I received a nicely wrapped present and it was that book!
ReplyDeleteYes, parishioners can have a sense of humor when it comes to their priest/minister.
DeleteAt a church rummage sale, someone donated a copy of 'The Joy of Sex'. I was thinking it was something that perhaps we shouldn't put out in case kids got a hold of it, since the drawings are explicit. One person was so outraged at my 'puritan attitude' that I decided that she had to be the one who donated it.
DeleteSince I would have put that in the DIY section, and I never saw any young kids browsing that section, I probably wouldn’t have been worried.
DeleteYou guys are a lot more organized than our church. The books were just set on shelves.
DeleteHonestly I think it is just a matter of scale. With fewer books that would be acceptable. But we had a regulation sized basketball court full of books so it would have taken a person hours to go through it all just to find what they wanted. With it sorted out, I could go through the non-fiction book section in about 15 minutes. If you wanted a romance novel, there were about six rows spanning the entire length of the "basketball court" so it would take you a lot longer but not as long as if they were all mixed up.
DeleteOur library stopped accepting books for later sales. I suppose they found the bit of revenue not worth the effort. Yours seems to have it well organized.
ReplyDeleteI don't know what the final numbers were but I heard that the first two days of the three day sale outsold last year. But last year was in the middle of a pandemic so I take that statement with a grain of salt. But I'm guessing it wouldn't be worth it at all if not for all the labor being volunteers.
DeleteOur library has a large book sale at least once a year. These days, I prefer to donate books to it rather than bring any home. (I have plenty... plus the entire digital library at my fingertips!) I did get tickled at your speculations on readers. I like my books like my music: quite varied, with a few favorite genres. -Kelly
ReplyDeleteAs the saying goes, assuming makes and ass out of you and me and I'm sure I got my stereotypes horribly wrong. In my wiser, older age, I'm the first to admit that I do judge people despite my best attempts not to but will readily fess up to being wrong about it. I don't know my overall percentage but it is probably close to 50/50.
DeleteThat would be such an interesting endeavor and I would also be curious about the readers of the various books. I do occasionally read romance and one of my favorite books ever is "Lonesome Dove" so I don't know that I fit into any category. I also enjoy sci-fi and mysteries. I don't read much non-fiction but loved "Boys in the Boat."
ReplyDeleteI loved Lonesome Dove back in my fiction reading days. I read most of McMurtry's books back them. I guess I would have put Lonesome Dove in the western category even though I know it probably wouldn't interest those that love the pulp western/gunfighter stuff. I found many books that crossed over between genre's and would just have to guess at whom it might appeal to most.
DeleteIts been along time since I read a book. Now I wonder how I read big fat books like "Roots"
ReplyDeleteI’ve read entire libraries out of books so your complete opposite. I really enjoyed Roots so much as a kid, I probably read it several times!
Deleteraising awareness for the local library would count as a good deed.
ReplyDeletethe chocolate clown corpse .. what a title!
I hope it counteracts anything negative I have done anyway.
DeleteInteresting post, Ed. I suppose the real test of a book is whether it gets sold or is one of the ones remaining after the sale, rejected by all potential readers.
ReplyDelete